Hickman County Times: Sludge in Maine is concerning (8/22/2022)

Last week, the Hickman County Times ran an article about a new ban on sewer sludge in Maine because of the dangerous “forever chemicals” that come from wastewater treatment plants.

I’m glad the Times is covering important issues like this, especially with Lick Creek still in jeopardy of being tainted with wastewater by the Water Authority of Dickson County. The WADC can claim their water is clean and drinkable all they want, but I’m not going to drink that water!

Save Lick Creek isn’t just about our creek in Hickman County or the people that live along it. It’s about saving Hickman County from the many harmful impacts of these toxic chemicals.

Do we want to protect Hickman County’s natural beauty, quiet way of life and health, or will we let these chemicals poison our county and our families forever? I am glad our hometown newspaper is helping us understand the seriousness of the issue and keeping us informed.

JEAN F. SIMPSON
Franklin

Hickman County Times: Fixing leaks better than building anew (9/26/2022)

Wastewater proposal

September 26, 2022

By RODES HART and AMANDA MATHIS Friends of Lick Creek

In a recent column, “Let reading infiltrate your weekend,” the editor of the Hickman County Times suggested that opposing the proposed Water Authority of Dickson County’s (WADC) new sewer plant in Hickman County could lead to a moratorium on new growth for our county.

He goes on to suggest one of the alternatives to building a new sewage treatment plant — fixing existing leaks — is not a viable solution and is a waste of money.

We respectfully disagree. This alternative (George E. Kurz Engineering Report — Sept 18, 2020) involves repairing the existing WADC system rather than building an entirely new plant in Hickman County. Fixing the problems with existing plants will certainly cost money, as will any project. However, fixing the existing plants will cost far less than building a new plant.

The WADC claims they need a new plant because their existing plants are over 90 percent of capacity, and more capacity is needed to support growth in Dickson and Williamson counties. The previously referenced study revealed that 61 percent of the water in the WADC plant is rainwater, not actual wastewater. If WADC fixes the leaks, the plants’ flow could decrease from 90 percent of capacity to less than 50 percent.

All that capacity is being wasted, along with the economic growth it could support. The question at hand here is why waste the capacity? Why build a new plant and take land from families in Hickman County to create capacity that already exists?

Think of it this way:

You need additional bedrooms in your home for family or guests to stay. However, you already have a three-bedroom house — a bedroom for you and two additional bedrooms that need a new coat of paint and some other repairs. Would you build two more bedrooms? Or would you utilize your existing capacity and simply repair your existing bedrooms? The choice is obvious.

Eventually, the WADC will need to fix their leaking lines. Will that be after they have spent tens of millions of unnecessary dollars on a new plant, or before?

To us, it is an easy answer. The WADC apparently never even considered this alternative in proposing the new plant as they are required to do. They have their sights squarely set on Hickman County.

The benefit of this proposed plant is not designed for Hickman County. Nearly all the projected wastewater comes from our wealthier neighbors, Williamson and Dickson Counties. This will result in 12 million gallons of treated wastewater per day being pumped into Hickman County waterways: Lick Creek, which leads to Duck River.

Let that number settle in for a moment: 12 million gallons per day is not a small amount of chemical effluent. Our water polluted, our land condemned and our way of life altered for a plant that does not even benefit the citizens of Hickman County.

We are certainly not anti-growth for Hickman County. We simply believe that growth and infrastructure decisions should be in the hands of Hickman County and be made in the best interests of its residents, its beautiful natural resources and its quality way of living.

Hickman County Times: Letter to the Editor – About the sewer line debate (12/7/2022)

I want to thank you for providing an outstanding local newspaper for Hickman County residents. We are fortunate to still have a local newspaper when so many are ceasing publication. I have often commented to friends and family that your editorship of the Times is a tremendous boost for our county. I cannot imagine a better weekly newspaper in Tennessee.

I read with interest your extensive coverage of the debate during the County Commission meeting of October 24th concerning Resolution 22-34, to extend WADC sewer lines to the East Hickman school complex. I have several observations.

With overall voter turnout at all-time lows generally, it is good to see some people still care about actions of their governing bodies and show up to voice their concerns. Your summaries of the public comments from citizens were complete and should be commended.

I do, however, have to take issue with one aspect of the coverage, notably in the “They act; we report,” opinion material.

It was stated that your goal was to correct misinformation followed by criticism of Amanda Mathis, one of the Save Lick Creek organizers, for saying that “it is abundantly clear that the WADC operates with a profit motive and they have very little oversight.” You went to some length to contact the Comptroller’s office to clarify they are not a for-profit business and do operate with some oversight.

She did not say they were a private for-profit company — just that they operate with a profit motive. WADC board members are not elected by the public and therefore not accountable at the ballot box. More importantly, the public water authorities are not like other government entities such as local governments.

For example, Hickman County and Dickson County governments operate within their jurisdiction. One county obviously cannot acquire a neighboring county. While technically a not-for-profit entity, the WADC can acquire other utilities to grow their business and expand service areas to increase revenue.

The more revenue they generate the more they can grow. This was part of the plan for agreeing to extend their service area to the East Hickman schools — and for the proposed Lick Creek treatment facility.

By contrast, you did not clearly question the inaccurate and misleading statements contained in the resolution itself, such as that the sewer system was not in compliance with the environmental regulations and requirements. A quick check on TDEC’s website would have determined that there was no compliance issue. It was noted that amendments were made to correct the misleading information but did not emphasize that those statements in the initial format of the resolution were clearly incorrect.

The Save Lick Creek issue was clearly related to Resolution 22-34. The complete coverage of the October 24th Commission meeting is appreciated by those supporting the efforts to preserve the integrity of Lick Creek and the overall Hickman County environment. Again, thanks for the long hours you devote to provide us a great local newspaper.

LIONEL BARRETT
Lyles

TN Lookout: Conservation groups file complaint seeking stronger oversight over wastewater plants (11/22/2022)

BY: DULCE TORRES GUZMAN – NOVEMBER 22, 2022 6:00 AM

 Bacterial bloom in Trace Creek.( Photo: submitted)

This story has been updated.

Attorneys at Southern Environmental Law Center are pointing to a “massive” bacterial bloom as a sign that rapid development is overwhelming the state’s water resources. 

In September, landowners living near Trace Creek in Dickson County noticed a film of bacterial colonies forming on the waterway and alerted the Harpeth Conservancy, an organization dedicated to protecting Tennessee rivers. Organization members noted that the film was most likely caused by sphaerotilus natans, a bacteria commonly associated with raw sewage, and traced the problem to the White Bluff Wastewater Treatment Plant– located directly upstream from the creek.

 Discharge flowing into Trace Creek in Dickson County. (Photo: submitted)

If left untreated, bacterial bloom can grow rapidly and deprive the local ecosystem of oxygen. As for humans, a bacterial bloom indicates that sewage is being improperly treated and can lead to pathogens and other risks to human health, noted Grace Stranch, vice president of conservation and policy at the Harpeth Conservancy. 

The creek also flows into the narrows of the Harpeth River, “one of the most highly-recreated areas in Tennessee,” said Stranch. 

In response, SELC attorneys filed an official complaint on behalf of the Harpeth Conservancy to the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation. Attorneys urged the department to impose stricter limits on the facility’s discharge permit and stop additional sewer connections until the problem is corrected. 

“Simply put, Tennessee regulators should not allow wastewater treatment plant operators to recklessly dump improperly treated sewage into our waterways,” said George Nolan, senior attorney for the Southern Environmental Law Center.

The Water Treatment Facility of Dickson County later issued a statement that it conducts regular inspections and that the facility is in compliance with TDEC limits for  water quality. 

“While the letter submitted to TDEC regarding permit TN0020460 suggests Trace Creek appears to have a bloom of sphaerotilus natans, no testing has been conducted by the complainant to provide a factual basis for that claim,” said WADC Executive Director Michael Adams.

The bacterial bloom is also indicative of how rapid development presents problems that can overwhelm smaller sewage treatment facilities, according to SELC attorneys. Recent state data shows that an estimated 59% of Tennessee waterways are considered too polluted to support basic functions. Nitrogen and phosphorus pollution – which can result from improperly treated sewage discharges – are some of the most common causes of stream impairment statewide.

The White Bluff facility– operated by the Water Treatment Facility of Dickson County–has a permit that does not include any numeric limitations on nitrogen or phosphorus discharges, according to SELC. The permit does prohibit certain wastewater discharges, and the WADC may be in violation.

“Until we have really good numerical limits for phosphorus, and nitrogen, we’re going to have issues where we will see the growth of these pathogens and algae growths,” said Stranch.

“It’s an issue across the state,” she added. 

Tennessean: We can grow responsibly and protect vital natural resources like Lick Creek | Opinion (12/2/2022)

The Water Authority of Dickson County needs to scrap its plans to pollute Lick Creek, Hickman County and the Duck River watershed.

Mike Butler

Guest Columnist

  • Mike Butler is the CEO of the Tennessee Wildlife Federation.

The Tennessee Wildlife Federation is dedicated to the conservation of our state’s wildlife and natural resources.

We are not opposed to growth, but we serve as the voice of reason and a statewide advocate for the conservation, sound management and wise use of our precious natural resources.

Across the state, but particularly in rapidly expanding Nashville, conserving those resources while still providing opportunities for economic growth becomes acute.

New and creative approaches are needed to ensure the health and abundance of our lands, waters, and wildlife.

Earlier this year, we worked with conservation partners at the Southern Environmental Law Center (SELC) and The Tennessee Chapter of The Nature Conservancy (TNC) to protect the Duck River, the most biodiverse river in North America, by upholding limits on the amount of water that a water utility district could withdraw.

Stakeholders must meet to solve water and wastewater treatment challenges

Currently, Hickman County, just west of Nashville, faces another threat to valuable water resources. The Water Authority of Dickson County (WADC) is seeking to build a new sewage disposal facility on Lick Creek in Hickman County.

Williamson County filmmakers Eyan and Ivon Wuchina produced a documentary about Lick Creek, a natural area in Hickman County, Tenn.

Lick Creek is designated as an “exceptional Tennessee water” by the Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation. The proposed plant could discharge up to 12 million gallons a day, over 90% of which will come from neighboring Williamson and Dickson counties.

Both counties are rapidly growing alongside the expanding Nashville region, and it is incumbent upon the stakeholders engaged in the issue of Lick Creek to find a creative and more efficient approach to address our growing water supply and wastewater treatment challenges.

The Federation has numerous concerns about this project from specific issues surrounding the plant, to broader policy concerns:

  • State water law, and rules, require that applicants seeking to discharge into our public waters must show that the discharge will not degrade the receiving waters. At this time, we know of no analysis to verify this to be the case of Lick Creek and this proposed plant. If 12 million gallons a day of additional flow, that will include unregulated pollutants such as PFAS, does not degrade a pristine, exceptional water and fishing stream, then we are concerned that a precedent will be created that virtually no proposed discharge will be deemed to cause degradation; putting other rivers and streams across the state at risk.
  • Lick Creek is the largest tributary of the Duck River, the most biodiverse river in North America. If discharges from a new plant flow into the Duck, it will negatively impact an already threatened watershed. Allowing the WADC to have discharge flow to the Duck, by way of Lick Creek, adds another significant impact to a river that already is facing significant existing, and proposed new, water withdrawals.
  • Lick Creek is a treasured fishing and recreation stream for Hickman County residents and visitors. As middle Tennessee grows, the demand for water-based recreation is exploding. A new sewer plant of this magnitude, discharging up to 12 million gallons per day into Lick Creek will impact these uses.
  • The WADC has not been transparent with or listened to the concerns of Hickman County and its citizens. In fact, there is no Hickman County representation on their unelected board. Although the WADC had planned the construction of a new plant on Lick Creek for several years, they did not disclose their idea to the public. Instead, they posted a small sign with incomplete information about the project near a bridge along the highway. Fortunately, someone did notice the sign and started asking questions. The answers to date have been vague and the information now posted on their website is misleading.
  • The WADC stated that the water downstream of the outfall will be safe and clean, even suggesting you could drink it. This is nonsensical, and there are existing examples of wastewater discharges that appear to have led to degraded creeks.
  • The WADC failed to investigate alternative options to a new plant dumping discharge into Lick Creek. A 2020 engineering study showed that over 60% of the capacity of WADC’s existing plant is lost through leaks in the infrastructure. Why not fix what you have before building anew? They have also not seriously considered directing the outfall to the Cumberland River, a river with much more ability to handle the flow. Yes, it is further away from the service area, but they already have a water withdrawal line to the Cumberland.

Seek smarter regional solutions in cooperation with TDEC

We share the concerns of the residents who have come together to oppose the WADC project, protect Hickman County’s pristine waters and rural way of life.

Mike Butler

The WADC needs to scrap its plans to pollute Lick Creek, Hickman County and the Duck River watershed.

We call for the water utilities that currently use or seek to use the Duck River watershed for water supply and wastewater discharge to come together with TDEC and seek smarter regional solutions that can save taxpayer dollars and produce solutions that can ensure the health and abundance of our public rivers and streams.

Mike Butler is the CEO of the Tennessee Wildlife Federation, one of the oldest organizations dedicated to protecting Tennessee’s wildlife and natural resources.

Tennessean: Williamson twins’ film captures resistance to Lick Creek wastewater facility (12/21/2022)

Cole Villena

Nashville Tennessean

Williamson County filmmakers Eyan and Ivon Wuchina have produced a nine-minute documentary about the Save Lick Creek movement.

Eyan and Ivon Wuchina never lost touch with their endless fountain of childhood creativity.

The 32-year-old twin brothers are award-winning filmmakers who’ve directed everything from comedy sketches to serious documentaries to a loving tribute honoring the 1987 comedy film “Ernest Goes to Camp.”

Many of their earliest creative memories came on Lick Creek, which winds through Hickman County near their childhood home in Williamson County. Long before they knew how to work a camera or storyboard a feature film, they spent their afternoons playing knees-deep kickball (that is, kickball in knee-deep water), fishing for crayfish and hiking through the tall trees surrounding the waterway.

The twins have produced a nine-minute documentary about the Save Lick Creek movement, that debuted at the Tennessee International Independent Film Festival in early November. The Friends of Lick Creek group is seeking to stop the creation of a Water Authority of Dickson County water reclamation facility in east Hickman County that would discharge into Lick Creek.

The WADC has stated it will treat the released water to meet Environmental Protection Agency and Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation standards, but advocates for the creek like the Wuchina twins are skeptical. Before additional development on the waterway moves forward, they want assurances that water quality will be maintained.

TDEC has not scheduled a public hearing on the application, and WADC doesn’t anticipate that will happen before the first of the year, according to WADC spokesperson Mark Drury.

As the twins return to the creek on a crisp October day, the memories come flooding back so quickly they finish each other’s sentences.

Ivon: “We grew up on a farm around here. We didn’t have cable when we were young. We’d just be outside.”

Eyan: “We’d just go play in the creek all day long. Go on creek walks … “

Ivon: “… walking in the creek with our dogs. Doing make-believe and all this fun stuff.”

The twins survey the creek, home to many fond childhood memories. It’s an idyllic autumn day, just after most of the leaves have fallen from the trees, and the only background noise is the occasional rural resident driving the long way round to their home.

It might not be quiet for long, they fear.

Ivon starts: “You go back to those memories and you feel like, if things like this move forward …”

Eyan: “… that experience for other people … “

Ivon: “… it’s going to diminish.”

In addition to the Wuchina brothers’ film, the friends group also recently released a 30-second commercial that aired on ESPN’s “College GameDay” and during the Tennessee-Georgia football game.

The Wuchinas’ film can be viewed here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wg3Al0ohvdg.

Williamson County filmmakers Eyan and Ivon Wuchina produced a documentary about Lick Creek, a natural area in Hickman County.

Hickman County Times: Letter to the Editor – Another threat emerges from Dickson Co. (12/26/2023)

In the 1960s Dickson County began taking waste from industrial chemical companies to dump in their unlined landfill. This hazardous practice was not generally known to the public.

As seems to be a tradition in this country, the landfill was located in the primarily African American community of Eno, along Eno Road in Dickson County. In this rural area all households in the Eno community were on well water.

In the 1980s ongoing testing of some area water wells alerted county officials to the presence of trichloroethylene, or TCE, a known carcinogen. White families in the area were notified of the danger and given the option to connect to the clean city water system. Black households were told not to worry, the water was safe and OK to use. Following this guidance, Black families continued to drink, bathe, cook, and wash with this highly contaminated water.

By the 1990s some of these family members started developing serious health issues, including cancers and autoimmune diseases. One family, the Holts, had several members who were seriously ill. Harry Holt, the patriarch, developed prostate and bone cancer that led to his death.

Sheila Holt-Orsted, Harry’s daughter, developed breast cancer that she narrowly survived. Only through radical surgery and aggressive chemotherapy was she able to make it.

Sheila teamed up with the National Resources Defense Council to file suit in federal court against Dickson County, the city of Dickson, and three large chemical companies on behalf of the Holt family and others in the Eno community. The Holts and NRDC were successful and received a substantial settlement.

Additionally, a federal order of consent was imposed on Dickson County to monitor area wells and be responsible for any future problems that may arise. This court order was only lifted in July of this year, 2022.

The Holts filed a second successful suit in civil court on the grounds of environmental racism. It, too, was settled for a substantial sum. Other area families followed, filing individual suits. All of these were successfully settled with Dickson County and the city of Dickson held liable for the injuries suffered.

Who ultimately paid for all this damage? Dickson County residents, who are reportedly still paying for it. However, no amount of money can ever repair this kind of suffering and injustice.

In February of this year another environmental threat was revealed in a public notice. Again, from Dickson County. (Remember the consent order was just lifted five months ago. Coincidence?)

This new threat is from the Water Authority of Dickson County (WADC). They have targeted Hickman County and Lick Creek as the site for their regional sewage treatment plant.

Why Hickman County? Well, why Eno Road? For the same reason — it looks like an easy slam dunk. Eno Road was a case of environmental racism. The Hickman County and Lick Creek threat is a case of environmental classism.

The vast majority of the sewage would come from Burns in Dickson County and Fairview in Williamson County. Two larger, more politically and financially powerful counties are targeting a traditionally rural and much less able one.

The reasons are the same in both cases — less able opponents, easy and quick profits. The outcome would be the same for Hickman County as it was for the Eno community. Our health and land compromised and put at risk so WADC can cash in on the maniacal growth of Williamson and Dickson Counties.

There are, of course, alternatives available. There always are, but they would cost more and cut deeper into WADC’s profit margin.

It seems acceptable to them to destroy our beloved gem, pure and pristine Lick Creek, and take crazy chances with our health and well-being.

We see through your ruse, WADC, and it is an insult to all who live, work, raise families and play along Lick Creek. You treat us like an easy mark to a hustler or a con man.

We have had this unwanted assault thrust upon us against our will. We will stand up and fight you, WADC. We are now part of a growing international movement of people being targeted by larger, more powerful communities and companies, like you, WADC, eager to exploit our natural resources and land.

We are viewed as a source of resources like fresh water, which is ever more precious and in short supply, and land to be used as your dumping ground. This predatory exploitation is fast becoming a national and global problem. And it is morally wrong.

You, WADC, have forced this new threat of environmental tragedy upon us. It is our duty to stand and fight for the beauty of our unspoiled land, the purity of our water, the peace of our rural existence and the health of our very lives.

To fail to defend ourselves and our creek would be shameful and dishonorable. This is our duty to what we hold dear, and this is what we must do.

BRAD SPAIN
Primm Springs

Hickman County Times: Utility files supplement to permit application (12/26/2023)

Lick Creek

December 26, 2022

By BRADLEY A. MARTIN

The water authority compared 17 wastewater alternatives, ranking Lick Creek first.

Treating sewage at a plant in the East Hickman area and releasing its effluent into Lick Creek is the least impactful and the most cost-effective of nine alternatives considered by the Water Authority of Dickson County to expand its capacity in the region.

That’s according to supplemental information filed this month by the utility. WADC’s original state permit application was submitted to the state Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) nearly 13 months ago.

The 30-page supplement — prepared by Water Management Service LLC of Nashville, which prepared the initial application — also includes a 25-page economic analysis of the region by Middle Tennessee State University’s Business and Economic Research Center.

The MTSU report says a sewer treatment plant would have a “sizeable” economic impact on the East Hickman and Dickson County areas — both of which lag behind the Middle Tennessee region in job creation — it says.

The MTSU study points to the lack of wastewater services as a missing link to economic development in the portions of the three counties that WADC serves, including Fairview in Williamson County.

“For whom is the benefit, is the question,” said Rodes Hart, a leader of Friends of Lick Creek.

In an e-mail following a query from the Times, Hart and co-leader Amanda Mathis said the additional information does little to ease their concerns about the release of treated effluent into Lick Creek.

“The revised submission does not address the fundamental inequity of taking waste from wealthier communities and dumping it in Hickman County and threatening some of the very things that make Hickman County special,” they wrote.

They said “legal action likely will be required” against WADC, to obtain “information and studies” on which its plan is based, for lack of compliance with the state’s openrecords act.

The December 9 filing comes at the request of the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC), which asked for clarifications last spring. The state agency will decide at some point whether to draft a permit. A public hearing must be held if that occurs; a decision whether to issue a permit would follow.

First, though, is this: TDEC must determine if it now has the data necessary to allow for a decision. If so, it then becomes required to make a draft permit decision within 12 months.

“We are still reviewing the submittal and cannot yet confirm if we have all of the information necessary to consider the application complete for a permitting decision,” said Kim Schofinski, TDEC’s deputy communications officer, said last week.

WADC’s December 9 submission was made on the same day that attorneys for Friends of Lick Creek filed with the state hundreds of letters and voice mails, and the results of a poll conducted last summer.

That poll collected 555 responses last June 23-26 by random e-mail and phone tests to registered voters here; it was not clear how many were asked for their views.

The result, as conducted by Cooley Public Strategies, showed that 86 percent of respondents were opposed to WADC’s proposal to construct a wastewater treatment plant near Lick Creek — as asked, “to dump 12 million gallons of sewage water into Lick Creek” — with 4 percent in favor and 11 percent unsure.

Tennessean: Middle Tennessee century farmer fights to preserve family land in changing world

Middle Tennessee century farmer fights to preserve family land in changing world

Space to live and breathe

Kerri Bartlett

ColumbiaDailyHerald | USATODAYNETWORK–TENNESSEE

Farmer Sam Kennedy III patiently surveyed the vast field where hundreds of sheep grazed peacefully at Kettle Mills Farm, the land tended by his family ancestors for 210 years in the Hampshire community in Maury County.

After a long day of herding sheep into the pasture, Kennedy look a moment to watch the burnt orange sunset on the horizon. As the quietness of dusk blanketed the farm, sheep and their eager lambs, chewed on fresh green grass before the chill of fall turns to winter frost.

The collective chews of 750 sheep resembled the methodical sound of locusts, only softer and gentler, a calming sound, resulting from a day’s hard work, according to Kennedy.

“Shhh,” Kennedy said, “listen to that. This is my favorite part of the day. The animals are content. They are where they are supposed to be, enjoying the land.”

Each day Kennedy drives his red pick-up or ATV across 800-plus acres to ensure the animals are fed and all is well.

During his daily drive, he often stops at the family cemetery, where generations are laid to rest on a grassy knoll that catches every sunset and sunrise. The cemetery is located past the Duck River, which borders the property, a symbol of constant, steady motion throughout the changing generations on the farm.

“If you give to the land, it will give back to you,” he said.

Sam Kennedy IV feeds sheep at his family’s farm, Kettle Mills Farm in Columbia. Sam, who is 6 years old, is in line to become the eighthgeneration owner of Kettle Mills once he comes of age.

His 6-year-old son, Sam Kennedy IV, one of his three children, trudges through the grass, climbing in and out of his father’s pick-up, enjoying the amenities that growing up on a farm brings — climbing headstones in the family cemetery — or hiding behind them — hanging on fences, leaping over tall grass and petting plenty of sheep with a guardian dog at his ankles.

Those are the experiences Kennedy is proud to pass down to his children, much like his own experiences growing up visiting the farm when his grandfather and his namesake, Sam Kennedy Jr., owned it.

Fresh air, starry nights — and the girl across the street — are just some of the memories that living close to the farm emblazoned upon Kennedy’s heart as a child. After serving in the Navy and the Naval Reserve around the world from Europe to Africa and in between, he found his way back to the farm in 2010 with a mission of carrying on his family legacy, preserving his family’s land in Southern Middle Tennessee.

“How can children build their imaginations if they don’t have the stars to look at each night,” Kennedy said. “I grew up with a love for nature and the land. That’s part of our family culture, something that has always been a part of me.”

Kennedy represents 95% of farmers in Tennessee who own family farms — land that many families are trying to preserve and make profitable amid inflation and rising production costs, while farmland dwindles in highgrowth areas in Tennessee, like Maury County.

Tennessee loses approximately 60,000 acres of farmland every year, according to the Tennessee Department of Agriculture. In Maury County, farmland decreased by 6% between 2012 and 2017, according to the 2017 U.S. Census of Agriculture.

“This has always been a dream that I think my father and grandfather have instilled in me I think,” Kennedy said. “I heard my grandfather tell tales, and I watched them on Kettle Mills my whole life. We never thought we’d be able to [sustain the land] as a living.”

His fondest memories are being able to “run wild” on the open land, building dams in the creek, building forts and later learn meaningful work each summer in high school and college.

When his family sold most of their land to a neighbor, the Morrow family, Kennedy was able to buy much of it back for the purpose of raising sheep and cattle to sell its meat to area stores such as Whole Foods.

A highlight for the Kennedy family this year is when Kettle Mills Farm was named in April as the Century Farm of the Year by the Maury County Chamber and Economic Alliance. The criteria of the designation is for a farm to be in the same family lineage and in consistent agricultural operation for at least 100 years.

There are currently more than 2,100 Century Farms in Tennessee with 19 certified Century Farms in Maury County, according to the Center for Historic Preservation housed at Middle Tennessee State University. Spread throughout Maury County, over 1,500 farms are in operation, according to the USDA.

Running family farm ‘not for the faint of heart’

Kennedy said the odds of him and his wife Rachel being able to run the family farm is “incredible.”

He admits that farming for profit is “a difficult task,” especially finding new ways to keep the farm prosperous for decades to come.

But through innovative farming techniques, much study, trial and error and experienced gained, Kennedy, an avid reader and researcher of new methods, has found some new ways to approach raising his primary product — sheep and cattle.

Rhedona Rose, executive vice president of the Tennessee Farm Bureau Federation, keynote speaker at the Maury Alliance Farm City Breakfast shared that farmland in the U.S. has been shrinking for the past 20 years.

Land loss has become prevalent as more and more residential and commercial development reaches high growth areas. The fastest growing land use is America is urban development, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

In the 20 years between 1997 and 2017, the U.S. lost 54 million acres of farmland, which is approximately the size of Minnesota, Rose said.

“You don’t have to drive far out to see that land once used for corn, wheat and pasture for cattle has been developed. We have lost that land forever to homes,” said Darrell Ailshie, agent for agriculture and natural resources for the University of Tennessee Agricultural Extension campus in Maury County.

Maury County is made up of approximately 227,179 acres of farmland, which is 57.9% of its landmass, according to 2017 data.

“In Maury County, we have seen a tremendous amount of growth, and there is pressure on families to leave the production side and look at other uses for the farmland.

“It’s economics. It’s hard to pencil out a profit for farming,” Ailshie said.

Kara Williams, director of Maury County Chamber of Commerce, who heads the chamber’s century farm program, said maintaining a family farm over generations is “not for the faint of heart.”

The organization has been honoring farmers through the Century Farm of the Year award for over 25 years.

“It’s a hard business. Prices and the cost of maintaining workers, like everything else, goes up year after year,” Williams said. “I have found that with most of our honorees, they want to be the best stewards of the land as possible, give back to their neighbors and improve the community. I consider them to be the first environmentalists.”

Finding new ways to create prosperity on family farms

Ailshie explained that many family farms add agritourism to its operations in addition to or in lieu of traditional farm operations by providing the public with “an experience through the fresh and local movement.”

“In order to keep the family farm together, families are getting creative by producing revenue through agritourism from Airbnbs to drawing people to the land for an experience whether it’s a hayride, a picnic, educational programming, shopping or being with the animals. They can see the cows in the pasture and meet the farmer who raises them. They can see where their food comes from and reconnect with the land.”

Kennedy has joined the agritourism movement by providing an Airbnb on the property, where visitors can experience waking up on a farm with wide open spaces to roam.

He has also implemented new and innovative ways to make the farm production side of the business profitable such as using the method of “planned rotational grazing” in raising his sheep and cattle, which eliminates the need to purchase feed like hay, thus reducing “off-farm inputs.”

Planned rotational grazing allows Kettle Mills sheep and cattle to rotate grazing spots on the land, promoting vegetation to grow back naturally on each plat as the herd changes locations.

“It mimics how the animals would really graze in the wild, how herbivores behave in a grassland environment. Once the vegetation is gone, they move to the next location to find more abundant food and to stave off predators,” Kennedy said.

It could take up to six months or more for vegetation to grow back on a certain plat of land, Kennedy said, but in the meantime, the animals are happily grazing on other parts of the property.

“The method keeps costs low and makes the farm less susceptible to inflation,” Kennedy said, which is key in sustaining profitable production.

Heart calls Kennedy back to farming roots

After serving in the U.S. Naval Reserve, Kennedy’s dream was to return to the family farm.

“The quality of the farmland defines the quality of life in a community,” Kennedy said. “Clean air and water and the space to live and breathe depends on the agricultural community.”

He followed in his grandfather’s footsteps in many ways, such as embracing farm life and marrying the girl across the street. Grandfather Sam Kennedy Jr. married a Finney, whose family also owned land in Hampshire. The couple went on to operate the combined farms as well as serve as owners and publishers of The Daily Herald newspaper until the 1990s. Their son, Delk Kennedy, Sam Kennedy III’s father, who spent most of his life working as a lawyer, is now carrying on the family’s dual legacy in media as owner and host of WKOM radio in Columbia.

When Sam Kennedy III returned from the Naval Reserve, he married Rachel Vest the daughter of cattle farmers next door, much like his grandfather’s matrimonial path.

“We grew up together. It’s a story as old as time,” he said.

The couple operates the farm together. While Sam herds sheep, Rachel might be feeding the new lambs by bottle, he said.

Being a farmer is one of the only professions that brings you closer to God — the creation and the creator — Kennedy said.

“There’s a spiritual aspect of being a part of the creation daily,” he said, in which sunsets, green grass and blue skies are a daily enjoyment that never get old.

Family history builds firm foundation

The Kettle Mills Farm, of the Anderson, Delk and Kennedy family, began in 1810 when Richard “Kettle Dick” Anderson (born in 1777 in North Carolina), purchased 2,000 acres in Hampshire along the Duck River, which would lead to almost eight generations of farmers.

In 1882, Richard Anderson Kennedy, the grandson of farm patriarch Richard “Kettle Dick” Anderson, built the first successful dam across the Duck River and a mill on the west bank. The mill operated from 1882 to 1956 and was vital to the prosperity of the families in and around Hampshire, leading to the development of two general stores, a family dentist, a post office and other businesses.

“That’s where it all started,” Kennedy said. “Pre-World War II, this was a thriving community that is gone now. It’s like the song ‘Song of the South’ by Alabama … My grandfather was one of eight, and the war came and every single one of them left, girls and boys, and my granddad and his sister were the only two who came back to Maury County.”

Now Kennedy and his wife own about 870 acres of the original land.

“There’s a weight of ‘don’t mess it up,’” Kennedy said. “I feel like there are dead ancestors pulling strings for us because of the odds of us being able to do this.

“In 100 years, we will wish we had more farms, not subdivisions. I want to preserve Maury County and fight to keep Maury County as beautiful today as it was for the last 100 years.”

Tennessean: How one rural county is fighting to save a pristine creek from pollution as Middle Tennessee grows (1/5/2023)

A battle in Hickman County over a wastewater treatment plant reflects the larger issue of environmental conservation as Middle Tennessee rapidly expands.

Key Points:

  • The Water Authority of Dickson County is proposing a new wastewater treatment plant along Lick Creek in Hickman County..
  • Supporters say the project is needed to handle growth in nearby Dickson and Williamson counties and would allow Hickman County to grow and attract business.
  • But residents are worried about wastewater going into a pristine creek and argue they don’t have enough say in the matter.
  • Before the project can receive state approval, a public hearing must take place. No date has been set.

Cecile Allen’s family has owned their farmland on Lick Creek in Hickman County for more than 150 years, harvesting hay and soybeans, and raising cows, pigs and chickens.

Allen, 84, has lived on the property for much of her life, except for the decades when she and her husband John moved to Atlanta to raise their children. The couple happily returned in their later years to retire.

“My father was a small farmer here and he made a good living, as did his father and his father’s father,” she said.

The property, 250 acres in unincorporated Primm Springs an hour west of Nashville, is fed by water from Lick Creek, which Allen said is a lifeblood for the farming community.

“The creek is beautiful and clean, and it fertilizes our crops in the spring if we’re lucky,” she said. “It’s just a wonderful thing.”

Hickman County residents Bucky Knecht, Cecile and John Allen pose for a portrait on the bank of Lick Creek Friday, Dec. 16, 2022 in Primm Springs, Tenn. Hickman County residents are concerned about a proposed plan for the Water Authority of Dickson County to build a wastewater treatment facility in eastern Hickman County that would dump treated wastewater into Lick Creek.

But residents of Hickman County fear their way of life is being threatened by a proposed sewage treatment plant that could eventually discharge up to 12 million gallons a day of wastewater into Lick Creek, raising concerns over possible flooding, contaminated wells, and environmental damage.

Adding to the frustration, they said, is the fact that the majority of treated sewage would be pumped from the much larger and wealthier counties of Dickson and Williamson.

Allen said Hickman residents only learned of the plans after a neighbor in January 2022 spotted a small public notice sign posted on a bridge on Highway 7. 

“We were horrified,” she said. “How can we people of poor old Hickman County fight this?”

A ‘David and Goliath’ battle

It’s a concern shared by small communities and environmentalists across the state as Middle Tennessee sees exponential growth, forcing tough decisions on how to expand infrastructure while preserving the region’s beauty and natural resources.

A sign reading "Save Lick Creek" rests outside a home along Beech Valley Rd. Friday, Dec. 16, 2022 in Primm Springs, Tenn. Hickman County residents are concerned about a proposed plan for the Water Authority of Dickson County to build a wastewater treatment facility in eastern Hickman County that would dump treated wastewater into Lick Creek.

Last year, the 16-county region encompassing Nashville topped 2 million people, with leaders expecting that number to grow to 2.5 million by 2040. 

While it may be good for the economy, environmentalists say the development is straining Tennessee’s more than 60,000 miles of rivers and streams.

A 2022 state water quality report found that nearly 60% of assessed streams and rivers were impared with pollution to some degree, up from 42% in 2012.

Mike Butler, chief executive officer of the Tennessee Wildlife Federation, said state leaders will need to come up with creative solutions to protect waterways as the population expands.

Emerging battle:Tennessee community fights to save their ‘exceptional’ creek

“The economic growth benefits a lot of people, but how do you make sure that it doesn’t ruin what is drawing people here?” he said. “For a starting point, we need to look at regional planning around water resources.”

The issue of conservation vs. development is playing out in Hickman County, where residents have waged what they see as a “David and Goliath” battle to save their own natural resource.

The Water Authority of Dickson County, which has proposed the project, says its three other wastewater treatment plants in Dickson and Williamson counties are all nearing 95% capacity. A plant in east Hickman is critical for population growth over the next two decades and would bring much-needed jobs and economic development to the county, the utility has said.

Hickman has long lagged behind its neighbors in economic development. A rural community, it has one of the state’s highest poverty rates at 16%, according to the U.S. Census bureau.

Its county seat of Centerville has a population of about 3,500 and boasts a bronze statue of native Minnie Pearl in the town square. To the east, its neighbor Williamson is the state’s wealthiest county, while Dickson County to the north is quickly growing. 

The water district, which serves customers in the three counties, said Hickman has been held back by lack of a sewer system.

Water flows along Lick Creek Friday, Dec. 16, 2022 in Primm Springs, Tenn. Hickman County residents are concerned about a proposed plan for the Water Authority of Dickson County to build a wastewater treatment facility in eastern Hickman County that would dump treated wastewater into Lick Creek.

In December, the water district commissioned an economic impact report from Middle Tennessee State University that found a new water reclamation facility in Hickman would create more than 900 jobs from construction and new businesses and $84 million in business revenue from new development.

The water district noted that it has had “informal conversations” with people interested in development south of Interstate 40 if a sewer service becomes available. 

But residents say the development shouldn’t come at a cost to their clean waterways. 

An ‘exceptional’ waterway

Lick Creek flows directly into the Duck River, which has been called the most biodiverse river in North America with more than 200 species of fish, mussels and snails. The creek is also classified as an “exceptional Tennessee waterway” due to the presence of the Coppercheek darter, a small, near-threatened fish found only in the Duck River system.

“This creek is pristine, and we want to keep it that way,” said Rodes Hart, one of the leaders of the group Friends of Lick Creek, which organized early last year to stop the proposal.

Maury County:Commission passes protection measures for development near Duck River

Hart, a Nashville philanthropist who owns property in Hickman, said the creek has supported family farms for generations and that the people here enjoy rural life.

“It’s a way of life that deserves protecting,” he said. “My fear is if some people get their way, there will be rampant development.”

While an exact location for the treatment plant has yet to be determined, the water district said Lick Creek is the best option because of its size as a large tributary. Other options, such as expanding current facilities or building a pipeline under Interstate 40 to the Cumberland River, would be too costly and wouldn’t be enough for future growth, the district has said. 

Long-time Hickman County Commissioner Keith Nash said local leaders were never consulted in the planning process and only learned of the proposal after an application had been submitted to the state. 

“It stunned me to realize how far down the road they had gone in this decision-making process without ever truly going to the group that has authority to speak to the folks here,” he said. “And honestly it hurt. I attend church in Dickson. These are some of the people I go to church with.”

Moreover, Nash said there are no Hickman representatives on the Water Authority of Dickson County’s five-member board of commissioners. Four commissioners are appointed by the Dickson city and county mayors, while a fifth at-large member is chosen by the other commissioners.

Opinion:We can grow responsibly and protect vital natural resources like Lick Creek | Opinion

Opinion:‘David and Goliath’ battle brews in Hickman County over the health of Lick Creek | Opinion

Nash said Hickman residents deserve to make decisions for their own county.

“My biggest concern is the loss of our ability to self-direct our community,” he said. “The ability for us to chart our own future is being wrestled away from us by someone who thinks they know better.”

Hickman County residents John and Cecile Allen walk down to the bank of Lick Creek Friday, Dec. 16, 2022 in Primm Springs, Tenn.  The Allens and Hickman County residents are concerned about a proposed plan for the Water Authority of Dickson County to build a wastewater treatment facility in eastern Hickman County that would dump treated wastewater into Lick Creek.

Bob Rial, mayor of Dickson County, said the water authority over a decade ago stepped in to help the sewer systems in Hickman and the city of Fairview in Williamson County as they struggled with growth. While there are no Hickman representatives, the board takes a regional approach, he said. 

Rial said he isn’t involved in the decision-making for the treatment plant, but believes it would be good for the region as a whole. 

“It’s a benefit for everyone because you want to be able to have clean sewer and water systems in rural areas,” he said. “It’s a necessity for all the growth we’re having in Middle Tennessee.”

Preserving Tennessee’s water quality

As of December, the water district’s permit application was pending approval by the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation, which oversees permits for pollution discharge into waterways.

The approval process requires a public hearing where opponents can raise concerns. A hearing date has yet to be set.

While the creek is classified as exceptional, the state allows some pollution in these waterways if the proposal can show it’s in the public’s best interest economically or socially. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency could review the application, but it does not review all pollution discharge applications, according to the state. 

While the state considers the permit application, the Friends of Lick Creek group said it plans to keep fighting to prevent pollution in its exceptional waterway.

Michael Adams, executive director for the Water Authority of Dickson County, in an email said water quality models for a new treatment plant show that Lick Creek would meet all federal and state standards for pollution discharge.

However, permits do not require testing for “contaminants of emerging concern” like pharmaceuticals and personal care products, which are becoming more frequent in waterways, said Dorene Bolze, president of Harpeth Conservancy, which works to protect Tennessee rivers. 

New film:Williamson twins’ film captures resistance to Lick Creek wastewater facility

And Bolze said there are no studies to show how those types of contaminants could impact aquatic species like the Coppercheek darter.

“We really don’t know how the creek would be affected,” she said. 

Bolze said the population growth has been especially overwhelming for smaller sewage plants in rural areas that discharge wastewater into small waterways. When levels drop in the summertime, many of those streams become almost entirely wastewater, she said.

“Some of these plants are discharging about 4 or 5 million gallons per day, and while that’s a relatively small number, it’s a big deal for small creeks and rivers,” she said. “We’re seeing more demand for highly treated wastewater.”

As the Dickson County Water Authority faces pushback in Hickman, it’s also seeing concern over one of its other treatment plants in the town of White Bluff in Dickson County.

In November, the Southern Environmental Law Center filed a complaint with the Department of Environment and Conservation over a possible bacterial bloom near a treatment plant outfall in Trace Creek. 

Photos submitted in the complaint show slimy green algae growing under water trickling from a drain pipe.  

George Nolan, an attorney for the law center, said it’s a sign of nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, which can result from improperly treated sewage discharge. 

The law center, he said, is urging the state to impose stricter pollution limits under the plant’s discharge permit.

Adams in a statement said TDEC conducts regular inspections for all of the water authority’s treatment plants and that the facility in question is in compliance with all state-mandated limits for water quality.

Rich Cochran, a manager with TDEC’s Division of Water Resources, said the facility’s current permit does not have daily pollution limits for nitrogen and phosphorus because Trace Creek is not on the state’s list of impaired waterways. The state will set total maximum daily limits, known as TMDLs, for a pollutant after it is listed as a cause of impairment for a waterway.

Cochran in December said field staff were expected to visit the site for an analysis and the state could modify the facility’s application permit to include limits for nitrogen and phosphorus. 

As small rivers and streams continue to see strain from growth, longtime Hickman residents like Cecile Allen said they hope it won’t happen in their community. 

“They haven’t started anything yet so we think we do have a chance,” she said. “I just hope and pray they can figure out something that isn’t Lick Creek.”